Sub Menu

Passionate About the Community
and the Moms Who Live Here

Recipes from the Homestead- Homemade Yogurt

Things are starting to get crazy here on the farm, spring is short in Vermont and we have a lot to do.

Our overdue cow, Olivia, gave birth to the most beautiful heifer calf, who we named Octavia.


With a fresh cow (the term used for cows who have just come back into milk) the flood of milk comes very quickly, and I am always rushed to drink and process as much milk as possible, especially since we will not be getting piglets for a few more weeks.

One of my favorite dairy products is homemade yogurt.

You do not need a cow to make homemade yogurt. A quart of organic yogurt can range from $3.00-$8.00 and even if you are buying raw milk at $10.00 a gallon, that still breaks down to $2.50 per quart of homemade yogurt. Ideally, a milk that is not ultra-pasteurized is best to use, but you can have success with any milk! (to source raw milk in your area, visit

Homemade yogurt is easy to make and the taste is slightly tangier than store-bought yogurt.

If you are feeling like an adventurous foodie or a thrifty mama, try homemade yogurt!!

Toddler in the Kitchen

Ingredients and Supplies Needed

  • 1 gallon raw or not ultra-pasteururized whole milk (can use 2%, 1%, or skim, but the product will be runnier)
  • 1/4 c storebought yogurt, (I use and get the best results with Butterworks Farm Whole Milk Yogurt) or yogurt culture (yogurt culture can be ordered online from New England Cheesemaking Supply, or Cultures for Health)
  • Yogurt maker or Large Ice Chest Cooler like this one that I use, or something that can incubate the yogurt by keeping a constant temperature for 12 hours, some people use their oven with the light turned on, or a hot water bath)
  • Large heavy bottomed stainless steel pot
  • Large spoon
  • Measuring cup
  • Thermometer
  • 4 Quart Sized Mason Jars with Lids


1}  Go milk your cow (if you do not have a cow and will be using store-bought milk, skip to step 2) 😉

2} Pour the gallon of milk in the pot, set pot over medium heat and slowly bring the milk up to 180 degrees Fahrenheit, stirring occasionally

3} When the milk reaches 180 degrees, take pot off the burner

4} Let the milk cool to 110-120 degrees. At this point add whatever yogurt culture you are using, stirring to incorporate



5} Pour milk with yogurt culture into mason jars and tighten lids.

Yogurt, Yogurt making

6} Place in whatever incubation device you are using and incubate at 110-120 degrees from 8-12 hours (the longer incubation, the tangier the yogurt will be, I incubate for 12 hours)

7} After 12 hours place mason jars in fridge to cool.

8} Once cooled, EAT and ENJOY! Our favorite way to enjoy is with a bit of Vermont Maple Syrup and  Adam’s Berry Farm frozen blueberries!

Recipe: Homemade Ranch (Yogurt) Dressing

Store bought salad dressings were one of the first products I kicked out the door on my journey to clean eating. They are often times loaded with soy or other rancid vegetable oils, sugar, processed dairy products and preservatives. This is not the reason I eat salads, so I went on a quest to create a homemade ranch dressing that mimicked the ranch dressing I grew up eating and loving on everything!

-1 c homemade yogurt (if you want a thicker dressing, strain the yogurt for up to 12 hours in cheesecloth)

-1 tsp each fresh or dried parsley and chives

-1 tsp onion powder

-1/2 tsp fresh ground black pepper (or to taste)

-optional: 1 clove minced garlic

mix everything together, let sit in the refrigerator for flavors to develop, at least 1 hour.


, , ,


  1. My Journey to Finding Self Worth, Without a Paycheck | Burlington VT Moms Blog - June 11, 2015

    […] I got pregnant with Stella, I was the manager of a small raw milk dairy. I worked 5 days a week at that farm and also relief milked for two more farms on a regular basis […]

  2. Bountiful Bacteria | Burlington VT Moms Blog - June 18, 2015

    […] realize it, but many foods in your daily diet have undergone some process of fermentation, such as yogurt, cheese, coffee, chocolate, alcoholic beverages and spirits, soy sauce, and more! I narrowly […]

Leave a Reply